Posts Tagged ‘sci-fantasy’
the first two The Ninth’s
Posted December 22, 2020
on:Happy Solstice!
Happy Jupiter-Saturn Conjunction!
Happy Holidays!
Hey, so you might remember that I when I’d put some books on hold at the library, I thought I was getting the first Tamsyn Muir novel, and OOPS, I put the 2nd book in the series on hold instead. Following the advice of literally everyone who said “for the love of anything that is holy, do NOT read these books in the wrong order!”, I bought a copy of Gideon the Ninth, and binged the shit out of it, before reading the sequel, Harrow the Ninth. And who is awesome, and managed to read both of these before Harrow was due back at the library? Yep, this girl!
I suck, and didn’t have time to write a formal review, let alone two. So, here is some random thoughts about these two books. There’s approximately eight billion reviews out there for Gideon the Ninth, so I kinda didn’t feel obligated to write up some formal, stuffy review. Since I’m talking about both books here, there (eeeek!) might be some mild spoilers. Also? since these books are snarky and sweary, so are my thoughts on them!
some random thoughts on Gideon the Ninth
- I’m more than a little in love with this cover art.
- ooh, Scif-Fantasy, I love it already! the Ninth house is kinda a shithole? but damnit, it’s their shithole, and they love it. and like, um, how come there is plenty of grown-ups living there, but like, no kids? That one sentence explanation doesn’t explain enough. There better be more explanation later.
- This book is 100% my sense of humor. Like, if you ever wanted to know what kind of jokes I like, just read Gideon the Ninth.
- so, um, is this The Hunger Games (but with snark) in space?
- Ummm. . . this book is making me want to do a lot of push ups. (I can do ten in a row now! up from zero a year ago!)
- blah blah blah, hunger games stuff. and then THAT SCENE. I don’t mean the “I wanna fight that thing!” scene, I mean the scene with the room that she’s gotta walk across. All she has to do is walk across the room, get something at the other end, and walk back, and OMFG I GET IT NOW. All the hype? That was the scene in which I understood all the hype!
- yo, bone magic is fucking cool.
- I love how Muir describes things! the unexpected adjectives, the sharp and spiky metaphors, SO FUN! SO EMO! I fucking LOVE IT. I am dying laughing because Harrow talks in a fashion that is totally normal to her and her family, but everyone else like “why are you talking like you’re in some 1920’s vampire movie?”
- omg, the memes! the references! I shouldn’t love them, things like this are supposed to throw me out of a story, but all I LOVE ALL OF THEM! they just made the scenes and the dialog even funnier!
- Teacher is kinda weird?
- Gideon and Harrow’s face paint is very cool. I love how much their face paint is “a thing”.
- Seriously, can I have babies with this cover art. Unrelated, I haven’t laughed this hard in ages!
- Ah, I get it, I think. They can work together and share knowledge, or hoard all the knowledge and keys for themselves. Which is better? sharing what you know and letting people be your equal, or being more powerful because you have knowledge that someone else doesn’t have?
- I LOVE how drastically different all the houses are! and their necromancy is different, I freakin love all this world building!
- I’m getting a kick out of how queer everyone is. Like, people can have crushes on whoever they want, who cares what gender someone is. Very cool. I really like how Muir describes people – their eyes, how they move. their eyes. seriously, the eyes have it.
- I really dig the sparing scenes.
- I love that Gideon just does whatever the hell she pleases. Like, she answers to NO ONE.
- Harrow, you did what?? Srsly, why the hell did you do that??? and now you have feelings for who?
- Harrow, your parents did WHAT? i actually can’t tell if that is awful/disgusting, or genius, or falls into doing what you gotta do so you can do what you gotta do.
- OMG THAT END. THE COST! I super can not wait to reread Gideon the Ninth next year, because since I know what’s going to happen, I can actually focus on the day to day in the story, and find all the nuggets that I was reading too fast this time to catch.
- Yeah, the annoyance of having to learn to fight with a rapier, and leave a broadsword behind? Yep, i get it now. Pretty. Fucking. Genius.
- Dude! the cost for that IS EXPENSIVE, as it should be, right? Things like that should cost you, and I deeply appreciate that everyone involved in the transaction understands the cost. or at least, they claim to. Tanstaafl, you know?
- um, I think I might have cried a little at the end.
totally unrelated, but I’m going to use a chicken carcass to make chicken broth. I’m using a dead chicken to make something. . . is that necromancy? hen-omancy?
LOL, confused yet? I tried not to spoil too much. Let’s move on to Harrow the Ninth!
- where are all my fave characters?
- I’d gotten so used to Gideon’s voice, that it’s strange to read a story from Harrow’s point of view. I personally, feel rather parallel to Gideon’s inner monologue and general attitude towards life, and I don’t relate as well to Harrow.
- Andrea! focus! this book is NOT from Gideon’s point of view! get over it!
- 2nd person perspective? really? ok, I’ll give it a whirl. better be worth it. Also, what the fuck is going on?
- So, Harrow is hanging out with a fellow necromancer, the two of them are hanging out in the other girl’s over-decorated apartment, and I LOVE how Harrow describes the apartment, it was a perfect description of visual sensory overload, which I can totally relate to!
- Awww, Harrow is such a cute little nun! She really has drank the Ninth House kool-aid, she really does believe in everything she’s supposed to believe in, she really is a prudish little nunlet who is grossed out when grown ups kiss each other, and that makes her even more adorable!
- Seriously. This isn’t how it happens. What the fuck is going on?
- John, you gotta explain this. all y’all grown ups can not keep hiding behind closed doors and not be explaining shit to the kids.
- Still kinda annoyed my fave peeps haven’t shown up yet.
- All the different ways to paint your face have different names and different religious meanings? Harrow I’m sorry I thought you were a silly little nun because i’m loving the symbology and communication through face paint, tell me everything about all the different ways to paint your face! I NEED this appendix!
- Harrow, what the fuck did you do to yourself, and why would you do that to yourself? Can you please not be a stubborn idiot for five whole minutes at a time?
- Yeah, that’s not how it happens either. try again.
- why does that guy keep trying to kill Harrow?
- hahahaha! that was a really good yo-momma joke!
- Sorry blondie, she’s just not that into you.
- um, I don’t really get all this river stuff? Maybe it’ll make sense later.
- WAIT. WHAT? back up, you’re going to have to explain, or I’ll just have to read this passage a few times, because this is super insane and cray-cray and holy shit!
- Huh. looks like someone hoarded their knowledge. I bet they would have been the jerk who wouldn’t share any of their keys. What a jerk!
- yep, the eyes have it. Also, this book wins for best dad joke possibly EVER.
In the end, I think I enjoyed Gideon the Ninth more than I enjoyed Harrow the Ninth. That doesn’t mean Harrow is bad (far from it!), it just means I preferred the narrative voice of Gideon. That said, in Harrow the Ninth, there is a whole ton of “what the hell is really going on here”, that broke my brain in the most wonderful way! And all that explanation, it needed to be in the second book. If all that had been revealed in the first book, everything that happens in the first book wouldn’t have been anywhere near as effective.
hey, so when does the third book come out? I hope that book has a lot of bones in it.
You’ve probably already figured this out about me, but I don’t mind it when an author doesn’t explain everything. I’d rather a story very slowly tease out the “what’s really going on”, rather than tell me all the fun stuff up front. Sheri S Tepper’s The Family Tree, published way back in 1997, is very much this kind of story. We meet some characters and get to know them . . we meet a second batch of characters and get to know them. . . and then, well, you might want to duct tape your jaw to your head, as some insulation against how many times this book will make it drop.
Also, whoever wrote the back cover copy on the paperback I have, man, that person managed to take an amazing, charming, enthralling book and make it sound kinda blah. So don’t read the cover copy!!
As with most other Tepper novels I’ve read, I was drawn in to the story immediately. The characters caught and kept my attention, and Tepper showed me their environment without infodumping. This is a very Tepper book, and by that I mean the characters are intelligent and persistent, there is a pro-environmental / live kindly with nature theme, and a long game.
We meet police officer Dora Henry as she’s realizing she needs to leave her husband Jared. They have the absolute strangest relationship ever, more a marriage of convenience than anything romantic. And when she moves her stuff out he flips out. (later in the book, when Jared flips out even more, I described him as a mustache twirling dick. My husband’s response was “but was he a dick twirling mustache?”. Dick twirling mustache is my new favorite way to describe a petty bad guy).
Even without the divorce and Jared’s drama, Dora has her hands full at work. There are some murders that her department is investigating (who would kill a scientist?) and invasive plants and trees are taking over the city. She doesn’t mind the invasive trees and plants, they are quite pretty, if you like that kind of thing (which Dora, and I, do)
So, just as I’m getting super invested in Dora’s plotline, the story shifts to this sort of quest fantasy plotline. My first thought was that Dora was telling this story to someone? Or that someone was telling this, as a bedtime story, to Dora in her childhood? Because it did have the trappings of a fantasy story – among other characters is the young harem slave, Nassif, who is told to dress like a boy and be a servant for Prince Sahir who is going on a quest, there is also Prince Izakar who has access to secret library and is told he needs to solve the great mystery of his time, there is a farming family whose humorous children only care that their grazing animals are safe, there is a countess, there are a few other characters. All these people end up meeting and deciding they should continue together, in hopes they can help each other on their possibly connected quests.
My second thought, after a few chapters of these fantasy style characters was how nice they were to each other. Sure, people disagree, but there was no backstabbing, no betrayals, no intrigue, no bloody wars of conquest. All these folks are, for lack of a better term, decent human beings who show kindness and compassion. (how sad is that, that I’m shocked to run into decent human beings in a sci-fantasy novel??) There does seem to be this thing about accusing people being cannibals, which was disconcerting and threw my idea of this being a bedtime story out the window.
Even Better This Time
Posted July 23, 2018
on:
Yep, The Scar by China Mieville is still in my top five list. Top Five Favorite Books, EVER. Yes, this book is that fucking amazing!
You know, sometimes you don’t read a book for years, and then you go back to it, and it’s not as good as you remember, and you wonder why you squeed so much over it in the first place, because yeah it’s a good book, but it ain’t great?
Yeah, so, The Scar was the opposite of that. I saw a ton more this time. I know the plot, I know what happens, I know the big reveals, I even know some of the tiny intimate scenes that really don’t matter. I know all of that stuff, I’ve seen it five or six times already. This read tho, this time I was able to see everything else.
I saw the creation of physical scars in the plot. I saw how those scars change people – sometimes it is a reminder of pain, sometimes a reminder of rebirth and positive change.
I saw every time Bellis was used. I saw that sometimes she knew when she was being used. I saw what that did to her.
I saw Tanner gain his freedom, and then gain it again.
I saw how language can give a culture freedom, and can also be used as a prison.
I saw what people are willing to do to get what they want.
I saw the mistakes I’d made in my previous reads of this book.
I saw that while I only wanted to look at Doul through splayed fingers, that I could listen to him with no fear. I found that I desperately wanted to be his audience.
Welcome to a spoilerific discussion of China Mieville’s The Scar. This book came out in 2002, so not only do I not feel bad about giving minor spoilers, I’m confident enough in my vaguebook abilities that if you’ve never read this book, none of this post will make any sense to you. And hey, if it makes you interested in reading The Scar or any other China Mieville? bonus!
Johannes confides in Bellis that Armada attacked the Terpsichoria because he, a famous scientist, was aboard, and they wanted his knowledge. Getting Johannes was just one step in the plans of The Lovers, we don’t even see their plans before Bellis and Johannes get to Armada. What did they do before? Did The Lovers know, or have an inkling that they’d need a High Kettai speaker? Could they have been on the look out for the woman who wrote High Kettai grammar books? Could they have orchestrated what happened in New Crobuzon to get her on a ship, with Johannes being just a bonus? And used Johannes to lure her to their side?
Iron Council by China Mieville
published in 2004
where I got it – who remembers? this book has been on my shelf for probably 10 years.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I’ve not read much of China Mieville’s newer books, but I went nuts for his Bas-Lag books – Perdido Street Station, Iron Council, and The Scar. Embassytown, having nothing at all to do with those books, falls in the same category of new weird/weird AF. The Scar has been on my “all time favorite scifi novels” list since I read the first chapter.
After ten years, it’s time to revisit. Let’s start with Iron Council. What do I remember about this book? Something about a rebellion, a train, a city that’s lost track of itself, lots of reMade, some reMade lady who is human down to her thighs and is a coal engine below and she has a younger boyfriend? Maybe?
Oh, the reMade? Yeah, so, there isn’t exactly prisons in this world. If you break the law (or piss off a rich person), instead of going to prison or a work camp or getting the firing squad, you get reMade in the punishment factories. Maybe you come out of there with a horse’s body, or fish scales covering your eyes or mouth, or guns instead of arms. Maybe you come out of there with a child grafted on to your back, or your face, or your feet switched with your hands. Maybe you’re not even recognized as something that was once human when you come out of there. But you can still work, right?
New Crobuzon is a bustling city, filled with industry, thaumaturgy, hedge magic, people just trying to make a living . There are rail lines within the city, but out in the wild lands? No easy way to get anywhere. A wealthy businessman incorporates, creates a railroad that’s going to go as far as it can. This is how New Crobuzon will make it’s name across the continent! (there’s a much bigger conversation here about what a railroad does when it goes through land. Who it helps, who it hurts, who benefits from it and who doesn’t, the human cost of the whole thing)
The further the railroad gets from home, the long the cash train takes to get there, the more weeks and months between when people get paid. The prostitutes were the first to strike, because they were sick of fucking on credit. When they stopped taking customers who had no cash, the rail workers striked, refusing to work another minute without pay, because no pay means no fucking. Even the reMade, who were technically slaves of the corporation, went on strike. The strikers took over the train, and fled into the wilderness, and took the train and the tracks with them. The strikers? Yeah, they the ones who know how to lay track, grade land, build bridges and blast tunners. The train was theirs now. The Iron Council was born out of a sex strike.
Discussing Gene Wolfe’s The Sword of the Lictor – Book of the New Sun #3
Posted November 25, 2017
on:- In: Gene Wolfe
- 3 Comments
Out of context, this printing of The Sword of the Lictor looks somewhat awful. The cover art is embarrassingly terrible, and the font size of the print is just small enough that it was hard for me to read. If I saw this paperback at a bookstore, and had no idea who Gene Wolfe was, I’d be like “dude. What the fuck.” Here, let me give you a closer up picture:
The terrible cover art and the too small print sums up my complaints. And now that I have that out of the way, I can get to what these Book of the New Sun posts have become – new words, questions and guesses, notes I wrote down while reading, stacks of hella awesomeness, and this far into the series there are unavoidable spoilers #SorryNotSorry.
Just joining, and have no idea what I’m talking about? You can read my previous entries about the first two books of the Book of the New Sun blog entries here:
A Hundred Pages Into Shadow and Claw – Just starting the first book, The Shadow of the Torturer
Thoughts and Questions on Shadow of the Torturer – Finishing The Shadow of the Torturer
A Little Further into The Book of the New Sun – Finishing the Claw of the Conciliator
And if you’d prefer a slower pace and much better thought out analysis, head over to the Alzabo Soup podcast, where they are doing a few chapters a week.
And if you’ve already read this series a bunch of times? No spoilers in the comments please.
For some reason, I didn’t start taking notes until I was halfway through the book. These books are so dense, with little gems hidden on every page, that without any notes of the first half, I feel like I’ve lost a part of my memory.
Not too many new words, or at least not many that I wrote down:
Estafette noyade atlantes oneiric
I found it funny that Severian keeps inflating his title. Maybe this is distance from his guild, maybe he’s just trying to scare people into respecting him, maybe it’s blind ego. When we first met him, he’d usually introduce himself as “I am but a journeyman”. He never rises to master, but in this book, sometimes he introduces himself as Master Severian. In one scene, he even introduces himself as Grand Master Severian. Maybe he’s trying to be confident, but he just comes off as egotistical.
- In: Gene Wolfe
- 8 Comments
I’m moving through The Book of the New Sun at a pretty good pace.
I’d planned to do two posts for The Claw of the Conciliator, so I could see how my thoughts changed from halfway through the book to when I finished it. I zipped through most of the book over last weekend, and by the time I was ready to write a post, I was only 20 pages from the end. So I finished it, and a few hours later, picked up the third book in the series.
Claw of the Conciliator is leaps and bounds more interesting than Shadow of the Torturer. For the length of the first book, we’re getting to know Severian, finding our footing in the world, de-coding weird words, and we’re just along for the ride. In Claw, Severian finally gets a chance to see the larger world, his eyes are opened a little bit as to why the world is the way it is, and we start to see the consequences of some of his earlier decisions. Also? Jonas and the Antechamber!!
But before we get to Jonas, new words! Not as many as I expected:
Indathrene
Campanile
Thaisus
Pelagic
Cultellerii
I already cried a bit on twitter about Jonas. Oh how I love Jonas! I was fascinated by how he avoids certain conversations, and gives Severian answers that sound vague to naive Severian, but make a ton of sense if you know where Jonas came from. I think Severian did eventually figure out, maybe? He was at least open to whatever Jonas wanted to tell him. I kept thinking about how language requires a frame of reference, and Jonas and Severian have different frames of reference. At this point in his life, Severian is still very sheltered, and Jonas, well, isn’t. I hope we run into Jonas again. He was good for Severian. Jonas and Dorcas seem to serve a similar purpose – to show Severian that the world is bigger than just himself. Those two have histories, lives, and dreams that are completely outside their relationship with Severian.
The Antechamber! When I figured out what the room was, and why these people were there, holy shit! It’s not a prison, not exactly. And I can why people don’t want to leave. They are waiting for something to happen, and it hasn’t happened yet, so they don’t want to leave and risk missing it. It’s like the rest of the House Absolute was built around this space.
And that dinner with Vodalus, and what they ate! That is a royally fucked up (yet utterly brilliant) way to share someone’s memories, i can see why it is considered taboo. But it seems to work? Severian now knows all this stuff he didn’t know before. I wonder what happens to the people who attend many dinners of this type, or specific dinners. Like, the whole thing is gross, but a super fascinating idea. Imagine if the alien critter that allows this to happen showed up on an episode of Doctor Who.
- In: Gene Wolfe
- 8 Comments
This blog post started here.
I didn’t realize I was reading through it so fast, I finished The Shadow of the Torturer (the first half of Shadow and Claw) last night. The first half seemed a bit trying to get through – strange language, a world that doesn’t quite make sense, episodic stories, and then we get to the 2nd half of the story that goes much quicker.
But first, more new words:
Coryphees
Anacrisis
Chiliarch
Bosquets
Deeses
Fewer unknown words in this second half.
And now for thoughts, questions, and spoilers!
Shadow of the Torturer ends very abruptly. It’s going, it’s going, there’s a sort-of duel, Severian gets to do his job, it goes a little more, slows down a bit, and then BAM it ends. Yes, I get the whole concept of ending on a similar note as the start, but it was still weird.
Severian sure is easy to manipulate. Get a pretty girl to say hello to him, and he’ll do just about anything. And if she shows some leg? He’s practically her slave. He is an absolute idiot to trust anything Agia says to him, and he seems to trust everything she says!
The house on stilts that is in the botanical gardens – is this a view through time or into another dimension? Robert and Marie seem of a more contemporary time. They look out the window hoping to see mail plane, and Severian hasn’t any idea what a mail plane is. Everything about the botanical garden rooms is hella cool! The rooms are bigger on the inside than you’d expect, it’s easy to get lost in them. The doors to the rooms, are they doors across space and maybe time?
Recent Comments