100 pages into Shadow and Claw
Posted November 1, 2017
on:This weekend past, I dug out all four volumes of Gene Wolfe’s The Book of the New Sun. Yes, i know physically I only have 3 books, but Shadow and Claw is TWO volumes of the series. This series has been called a modern masterpiece, a “must read” for anyone who calls themself a science fiction reader. I read Shadow and Claw a handful of years ago (three years? eight years? i have no idea) and enjoyed it. I remember it being heavy, beautiful, mythic, unforgettable, groundbreaking, strange, sci-fantasy dying Earth. I barely understood it. It was like reading a dream.
I do most of my reading on weekends when I have large chunks of uninterrupted time. By Sunday night I was 100 pages into Shadow and Claw. The (unreliable? kinda crazy?) narrator Severian is talking about his youth as an apprentice in the Torturer’s Guild. In a more modern epic fantasy, this guild would be the Justisters, I suppose – people who mete out punishment without thought for if the person is guilty or if the punishment fits the crime. In Severian’s world, there is an all powerful Autarch who holds concubines as hostages and does who knows what else, strange machines that speak when they feel like it, a rebellion, the dangers of waiting, a library that holds books older than history, The Citadel, and an entire civilization outside the Citadel who thought the Guild of Torturers died out generations ago. The story is presented episodically, with a much older Severian telling you what he thinks you need to know and sometimes apologizing for spending time on needless details. This is a world in which so much has been forgotten.
Anyway, forget all of that. You don’t need any of it. At least not yet.
Because it’s the words that Wolfe uses to tell this story, and therein lies the magic. I found so many words in this book that I don’t know the meanings of, giving them the shimmer of magical spells. Are these real words? Where they once words in a language that was forgotten hundreds of years ago? Are they satirical? Simply nonsense? I have no idea. They are like stones in a riverbed – smooth on one side, rough on the other. Here are a few:
vitiated
inutile
saffian
pursuivant
agathodaemon
thurible
peccary
pardine
caique
bartizan
See what I mean, that they are like stones that have smooth spots and rough spots? Say them out loud and you’ll see what I mean. Say them out loud and you can tell me how they should be pronounced. If these words were stones we could build a road by which to travel to the answer. If they were stones we could build a tower, and from the top of the tower we could see the answer. Every new and strange word is another stone, another step in the right direction.
Which of those are real words, or were at one time? Maybe they aren’t river stones with which to build a road or a tower, but memories and myths. A last attempt to bring back lost knowledge of a dying world.
Who knows what the next 100 pages of this book will bring.
1 | Richard Robinson
November 1, 2017 at 12:16 pm
I tried the first book, Shadow of the Torturer but didn’t like it much and dropped it a third of the way in. Haven’t gone back to him since.
LikeLike
Redhead
November 1, 2017 at 8:33 pm
it is certainly not for everyone!
LikeLike