the Little Red Reviewer

Supernatural Sherlock Holmes adventures from Christian Klaver

Posted on: February 11, 2015

Klaver HolmesSherlock Holmes and Count Dracula: The Adventure of the Solitary Grave (2009) and Sherlock Holmes and Watson: The Adventure of the Innsmouth Whaler (2010), by Christian Klaver

where I got them: received free copies from the author (thanks Christian!)




I don’t often step outside my comfort zone. It might seem like I do, but I don’t. Sometimes I need a little nudge, and sometimes that nudge comes in the form of the right conversation at exactly the right moment.  I met author Christian Klaver at Confusion, and came home with a few of his books.  Two of them were skinny little novellas, I could read these in an afternoon, right?  One had Count Dracula on the cover, the other made reference to Lovecraft. Sounds right up my alley, right? Not Quite. These are Klaver’s Supernatural Sherlock Holmes mysteries. I’m all for a smart thriller, and I’m all for anything Innsmouth, but Sherlock Holmes?  Judge me as you will, I’ve never read any Sherlock Holmes. I couldn’t even get into the new TV show. Totally lame, right? Only way to fix it was to jump into some Holmes, and out of my comfort zone (why is this stuff outside my comfort zone? I actually have no idea).


Like many of the original Holmes novels (thanks Wikipedia!), The Adventure of the Solitary Grave and The Adventure of the Innsmouth Whaler are narrated by Dr.  Watson. He’s telling these stories late in his life, after the death of Holmes. The two of them had agreed that these supernatural stories were far too unbelievable, but that after the death of the famous detective, the stories should be told. I really wasn’t sure what to expect, stodgy dry prose? Over-ornamented and boring dialog? Like something out of a play? Whatever it was that I expected, I got something completely different. I imagine that Klaver is a huge Holmes and Arthur Conan Doyle fan, and modeled his Watson and Holmes off the originals. What’s important here is that I quickly came to enjoy Watson’s voice and story telling style. These two stories were easy to get into, and highly enjoyable to read.


If you are going to read these, you need to read them in order. Read The Adventure of the Solitary Grave first (I just realized I photographed the books in the wrong order), because there are two events that take place that color the rest of Watson’s life and make permanent changes to his professional habits.  Of the two, my favorite was The Adventure of the Innsmouth Whaler. I’ve read my share of Lovecraft and Lovecraftian inspired fiction, and it was quite funny to hear Holmes guesses as to what was going on. He even tries to contact the authorities in Innsmouth and Arkham, and is puzzled by the useless responses.  Even with his powers of deduction he can’t quite fathom what’s happening.  Watson has the advantage here, as he’s more open to the idea of something beyond the understanding of man.

The mysteries and the plot twists were fun and satisfying, but what really made these stories for me was the characters (all you Holmes fans are collectively saying “duh” right about now, I’ll bet!). Holmes’s cold logic borders on heartless, rarely noticing when Watson either solves everything for them, or makes a joke at the detective’s expense. Watson is quiet and reserved, smarter than he lets on, loyal to Holmes, but hoping to avoid dangerous situations. The two of them sometimes banter, sometimes communicate wordlessly, and often reference (so far) unpublished cases and mysteries they have solved. I absolutely adored Watson’s narrative voice. I can’t vouch for anything due to my lack of experience with the original material, but many of the online reviews for Klaver’s work speak to his getting Watson and Holmes’s voices and attitudes just right, and giving the standard Holmes mystery a supernatural twist that blends right in with the original material.


Lots of good has come out of me reading these:  I’ve ventured out of my comfort zone and survived the tell the tale!  I’ll be reading more of Christian Klaver’s work, such as Shadows Over London. And I might even pick up some Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Sherlock Holmes!

Shadows Over London

7 Responses to "Supernatural Sherlock Holmes adventures from Christian Klaver"

FWIW the old Sherlock books are short enough to breeze through and are really nothing like the common image of him in TV. Hounds of Baskerville deals with something people think is a werewolf type monster that our man must prove otherwise.

These look pretty good too, especially the Whaler.


that’s a good thing, as the TV version didn’t thrill me.


Haha – I have literally just danced a fucking jig – for once I can sit with my arms crossed nodding and going ‘duh’ *because, yes, Holmes fan* ! I’ve read all the Sherlock Holmes books so I’m really interested in these. Thank you again you so-and-so for making me want to buy yet more books!!! I will look into these.
Lynn 😀


” ‘duh’ *because, yes, Holmes fan*! ”

Good! and yay for Jig dancing! Which are your favorite Holmes mysteries?


OMG – I would literally have to go and look back through my books! (My dad gave me the complete series – I think it’s complete anyway!) I’ll have to go and look now. I just like the writing style and the voices of the characters. They’re actually very typical for the era they were written – terribly civilised and even the mysteries are incredibly gentle really – well, they involve murders and poisoning and the like but they’re not violent or bloody books – they’re more about the process of unravelling the mystery and I was always intrigued by how ACD would come up with this intricate explanations for how he found the villain. They’re not for everyone of course and I read them in my teens so whether I’d enjoy them now – who knows!
I’ve added the Klaver books to my wishlist though – I’m always interested in revisiting Holmes and Watson.
Lynn 😀


You’d expect me to say the original Conan Doyle Sherlock Holmes stories are the best, and you’d be right, so okay, I’ll say it. They are the best; everything else is a tribute, pastiche or copy. But what the hell, anything that will get you to read any Holmes is a step in the right direction, so good on you.

There are a couple of very good steampunk London Holmes pastiche novels written by George Mann: The Will of the Dead and The Spirit Box that I think you’d enjoy.

Liked by 2 people

you’re completely right – these are tributes and homages. and right again, anything that gets me to read anything with the names Holmes in it is a good thing. (here’s a sad secret: for most of my upbringing, my only exposure to Sherlock Holmes was those cheesy episodes of Star Trek: TNG when the holodeck goes haywire and Moriarty is wandering around the Enterprise).

I’ve seen a few George Mann titles floating around, namely The Affinity Bridge and The Osiris Ritual. Are those any good, or should I just stick with his Holmes books?


join the conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow me on Twitter!

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,619 other followers

Follow the Little Red Reviewer on



FTC Stuff

some of the books reviewed here were free ARCs supplied by publishers/authors/other groups. Some of the books here I got from the library. the rest I *gasp!* actually paid for. I'll do my best to let you know what's what.
%d bloggers like this: