17 Responses to "Catching up with Classics: I Robot"
I was just having an interchange in the comments on my blog about how much I like I, Robot. I loved reading it because it was almost like a puzzle, as each story went deeper into the fine details of the Laws. I like a lot of Asimov, especially his short stories.
Great Review!
LikeLike
What is also cool about it is how those various stories make up the overall narrative, each one with further insight into the ways in which humans interact with said robots.
LikeLike
I’ve been meaning for a while now to try some Assimov but I still feel somewhat intimidated by him. I’m not sure if I’m prepared for the hardcore SF. But this book sounds like it might one I would enjoy. I’ll have to give it a try.
LikeLike
I was watching I, Robot on tv the other night, and found myself thinking, “What the heck does this have to do with Asimov’s stories?” Aside from the Susan Calvin character, the three laws, and US Robotics, it seemed unrelated.
LikeLike
I love the I, Robot collection. Great stuff. That and the original Foundation trilogy are some of my favorite books. Very good stuff. I have to admit that I like the film as well. I don’t mind that it is only marginally based on what Asimov wrote (although if you read the short story Robot Dreams that he wrote in the 80’s, that story is pretty prominently featured in the film), I find it to be an interesting and entertaining action film. But I know I’m in the minority on this one.
The Powell and Donovan characters in the short stories are a hoot. They remind me somewhat of the Odd Couple in their interactions with each other at times. And Susan Calvin is a perfect character to examine humanity through, as she often seems less human than the robots in the stories (this again is particularly apparent in the story Robot Dreams). We got into a long, long discussion about the I, Robot stories on the Classic Science Fiction Book Club site a few weeks back and it was fun revisiting my thoughts on these stories during that discussion. Those who don’t take the time to visit the classics are really cheating themselves of some marvelous reading, and that is a real shame.
LikeLike
Have you ever read any of Robert Sheckley’s short fiction? He has a couple of guys who run the AAA Ace Interplanetary Decontamination Service and those characters remind me of Powell and Donovan. Or actually vice versa since I read the Sheckley before reading Asimov. Fun stuff.
LikeLike
[…] Catching Up with the Classics: I, Robot at the Little Red Reviewer (review of the original Asimov book) No comments yet […]
LikeLike
1 | Tasha
February 19, 2011 at 2:35 pm
This is one that I really want to read. Thanks for sharing a great review! Tasha @ A Trillian Books
LikeLike