the Little Red Reviewer

Dying Inside, by Robert Silverberg

Posted on: September 28, 2010

Dying Inside is the intimate memoir of David Selig, who had the power to read people’s minds.

As a young child, David realized he could do something other people couldn’t. A bored child, he used his powers to see what girls were thinking, to spy on his parents, and to confuse the school psychologist. We’re so used to stories where a protagonist with special powers is drawn to use their powers for good, it was refreshing to read about a mutant who doesn’t use his powers for good, or bad, or anything except occasional mostly harmless fun. David eased his way through school (he could find the exam answers in the teacher’s mind), through dating (he really knew what women wanted), through many jobs, trials of life, etc. And it’s made him lazy. Why work when you can freelance a little here and there for money? Why stay in a relationship when you know your partner is no longer interested, but you don’t know how to tell her you know? How can you ever have a normal conversation or a normal life when you always know exactly what the person is thinking? He hasn’t been surprised by anything in a long time. He can count on one hand the people he has shared his secret with.

Soon David will be forced to have a “real” relationship with someone, to have a “real” conversation with someone, to enjoy the surprises in life, because his mental powers are waning. Some days he gets static, some days he gets nothing, and he has never been so scared in his entire life.

The story jumps between first and second person perspective, with David mostly narrating his middle-aged life, and Silverberg giving an “over the shoulder” feel to flashbacks to David’s childhood. Sometimes David jumps into second person when talking about his present failures and feelings, as if he can separate himself from the sad, pathetic person he has become. The novel takes place over the course of a year of his life, David attempts to reach out to his estranged sister in a real, honest way, while realizing that he’s wasted his life in more ways than one. This is not one of those books preaching that “mutants” need to use their powers for good. David wasted his life because he never had an honest relationship. He never had that closeness, that intimacy that the rest of us experience. He could look into anyone’s mind, into anyone’s soul, and it made him the loneliest person on earth.

David may be a sad, pathetic character, but in no way is this a sad book. It’s just a story, about a guy who can finally say that he’s normal, and he’s not sure how to feel about it. Feeling “normal” is strange, if it isn’t normal to you.

As with other Silverberg novels I’ve read, I had to keep reminding myself I was reading fiction, as the prose and style of the novel feel more memoir than fiction. There is plenty of drama between David and his sister, but it’s never over dramatic. Brothers and sisters everywhere will recognize the conversations, fights, and tensions between David and Judith as common sibling arguments.

Silverberg could have easily turned Dying Inside into a story about a man with a special power who becomes a superman, who uses his power for good. But David isn’t a superman, he isn’t interested in becoming famous, or helping people. In fact, the idea of “using his power for the good of the world” is never brought up, because I think part of what Silverberg is trying to tell us is that being special is not at all related to the person’s interest in being special. Originally written in 1972, this new printing offers an introduction by Silverberg, who is amused with the memory of presenting his original manuscript to his editor, whose said she was fearful for him while he went through a midlife crisis. Silverberg recounts that this is not a midlife crisis book, but simply a book about changes. Our lives change, our abilities change, and we can be depressed and fearful of the changes, or we can relish the new world that opens up to us if we would only let it. Silverberg’s style comes off as relaxed, but shining with the subtleties that show time and time again his artistic talent as one of the leading authors of our time.

Perhaps it’s the summer blockbuster movie advertising, but I couldn’t help comparing David’s powers to something that would be in an X-Men movie (minus the action), and then thinking about what would happen if Wolverine suddenly came down with a nasty case of rheumatoid arthritis.

7 Responses to "Dying Inside, by Robert Silverberg"

Love the last line- have a visual of Hugh Jackman gasping with pain at trying to use those indestructible claws to save himself or some helpless victim.

Anyway, I enjoyed your review. I’ve never read any of this author’s books (I think since I’ve been keeping tabs). This sounds truly interesting. When you called him a mutant, I thought of him as a mute at first. Never thought of a mind reader as a mutant, just someone with special powers, but that would be wordy for a review. I like the thought that he has to have real relationships and live a “normal” life. Really it’s a great review, and makes me want to read the novel when I’m a YA reader. But I think I’m starting to need some thing that have a little more meat to them.

Buried in Books


Happy you liked it! This could certainly be a “gateway” book into more meaty stuff, as on the surface it is fairly light reading. It really is a wonderful book. Robert Silverberg has the midas touch when it comes to superb writing.


Robert Silverberg is another one of those authors whose books I keep meaning to read but have never got around to doing do. This book sounds really good though, and very different from the other books of his that I have seen. I definitely want to read this now. Thanks for the review!


Sounds interesting!


When I read Dying Inside, I had only started to edit books for a living the year before. I found this to be an extremely sophisticated book that somehow manages to be easy and fun to read. Silverberg’s handling of viewpoints and tenses is masterful.

Here’s a gratuitous link to my review of the book: Magnificent Nose: Dying Inside.

Can you recommend anything else the author wrote that’s in this vein?


hmm… I could read a Silverberg every month for the rest of my life and not finish his entire oeuvre. I’ve read mostly his Valentine series and a few of his science fiction books. When I think “what’s similar to Dying Inside?” the only title that comes to mind is The World Inside, which although completely, utterly different, seems to evoke a similar feeling of desperation.


[…] in a more comprehensive summary, this review at the Little Red Reviewer has that and more: Dying Inside, by Robert Silverberg GA_googleAddAttr("AdOpt", "1"); GA_googleAddAttr("Origin", "other"); […]


join the conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow me on Twitter!

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,616 other followers

Follow the Little Red Reviewer on



FTC Stuff

some of the books reviewed here were free ARCs supplied by publishers/authors/other groups. Some of the books here I got from the library. the rest I *gasp!* actually paid for. I'll do my best to let you know what's what.
%d bloggers like this: